| # | Swimmer | Team | Seed | Time | Diff |
| 1 |
Knobler, Sera A (17)
|
MRAGUA |
5:22.74 |
5:18.81 |
-3.93 |
| 2 |
Lachman, Margaret (16)
|
MRAGUA |
5:28.63 |
5:23.94 |
-4.69 |
| 3 |
Frey, Sophie G (17)
|
MRNYSA |
5:33.75 |
5:39.51 |
5.76 |
| 4 |
Adams, Caroline E (16)
|
MRRAC |
5:37.64 |
5:49.57 |
11.93 |
| 5 |
Kascle, Raeanne (17)
|
MRRAC |
5:47.50 |
5:51.27 |
3.77 |
| 6 |
Cabanillas, Kimberly (16)
|
MRCSC |
6:09.17 |
5:56.80 |
-12.37 |
| 7 |
Costanzo, Erica (15)
|
MRRAC |
6:02.86 |
5:59.09 |
-3.77 |
| 8 |
O'Brien, Megan A (16)
|
MRNYSA |
6:26.93 |
6:07.38 |
-19.55 |
| 9 |
Christensen, Marcella R (15)
|
MRNYSA |
6:13.18 |
6:13.77 |
0.59 |
| 10 |
Harvey, Megan F (16)
|
MRNYSA |
6:25.95 |
6:20.02 |
-5.93 |
| 11 |
Armstrong, Dana E (17)
|
MRNYSA |
6:24.83 |
6:25.96 |
1.13 |
| 12 |
McKevitt, Katelyn C (15)
|
MRCSC |
6:32.32 |
6:26.67 |
-5.65 |
| 13 |
Fafian, Katherine A (15)
|
MRRAC |
6:09.15 |
6:50.77 |
41.62 |